Celtic face tough choice between O'Neill and Keane for manager role

Martin O'Neill and Robbie Keane are the top candidates to become Celtic's next permanent manager after their strong records in interim spells.

Main candidates emerge Martin O'Neill and Robbie Keane are reported to be the leading candidates to take over as Celtic's new permanent manager. The club's board is preparing to hold discussions with both individuals as they aim to finalize an appointment quickly before a critical summer period for the Scottish champions. After coming out of retirement, O'Neill guided Celtic to both league and cup success across two interim spells this season. Keane has begun his coaching career abroad, starting in Israel and later Hungary, where he has achieved notable accomplishments. ## O'Neill's interim impact Ten days ago, 74-year-old Martin O'Neill lifted the Scottish Cup, completing an impressive double during a turbulent season at Celtic. He stepped in twice after previous managers Brendan Rodgers and Wilfried Nancy departed. O'Neill appeared visibly fatigued at Hampden and admitted that if the season were to start immediately, he could not continue in the role. He also expressed that Celtic may need a younger manager. Despite this, he did not rule out returning in some capacity and emphasized his satisfaction in proving older managers could still contribute meaningfully to the game. ## Steady leadership delivers title Martin O'Neill's steady leadership guided Celtic to their fifth consecutive league title on the final day of the season, with a victory over Hearts. Players praised his influence during this period. If his average points tally across the Premiership campaign is projected, Celtic would have won the league with greater ease. O'Neill acknowledged learning from his assistant coaches Shaun Maloney and Mark Fotheringham, and the trio may continue together even if it is just for another year as the club undergoes rebuilding. ## Keane's managerial progress Robbie Keane, now 45, has been a frequent name linked with the Celtic manager role for much of this season. His stock rose further when he left his position at Ferencvaros last week after 16 months. Keane sought early opportunities in management and took his first role abroad with Israeli club Maccabi Tel Aviv in 2023. He secured a league title there before moving to Hungary to join Ferencvaros in January 2025, helping them clinch a seventh straight championship that season. ## European achievements stand out Despite financial advantages, Keane's Ferencvaros side failed to defend their Hungarian title this season, losing 1-0 to eventual champions ETO Gyor in April. This was their only defeat in their last 11 games, and they finished one point behind. They did win the Hungarian Cup as consolation. However, their international performances were more impressive. In the Europa League, despite falling to Qarabag in the Champions League play-off round, Keane's team reached the last 16 with a smaller budget than many rivals. They defeated Rangers, Genk, RB Salzburg, and Ludogorets, and drew away at Fenerbahce. ## Keane's football philosophy Ferencvaros often played in a 3-5-2 formation under Keane, who has described his football as attacking. He once stated his preference for direct play, saying 'I don't like my centre-backs keeping the ball for the sake of keeping the ball.' Keane has indicated a willingness to take bold decisions to maintain an aggressive style. Potential assistants mentioned for Keane include former Celtic captain Scott Brown and youth coach Jonny Hayes, along with former Aberdeen manager Stephen Glass, who has previously worked with him in Hungary. ## Fans debate the next move Supporters have shared mixed views on the potential appointments. One fan, Henry, suggested sticking with O'Neill if he is willing to continue, then bringing in a new manager alongside him early next year. Edward argued Celtic should retain O'Neill for another season but acknowledged Keane's strong connection to the club, even though a vocal minority would oppose him. John believed O'Neill's retention would be the obvious choice if he is up for it, allowing him to shape the squad early, possibly with Maloney continuing as his successor later. James added that if O'Neill stays another year, few would object, but it would likely be a short-term solution leading to another search in 12 months.